THREE QUESTIONS ABOUT DUTCH CARIBBEAN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS
FAQ
Question 1
Are there any particular issues that concern foreign plaintiffs in the Netherlands Antilles?
If proceedings on the merits are initiated by a non-resident plaintiff, the defendant may ask the court to order that the plaintiff provide security for damages, costs and interest which it might be liable to pay as a result of the judgment in aforementioned proceedings. This “cautio judicatum solvi” does not apply if there is a Convention (Treaty) on legal proceedings between the Netherlands Antilles and the plaintiff’s country.
Question2
Can attorney costs for legal proceedings be recovered?
Generally speaking, each party has to …
Read the rest »
CAN A FOREIGN COMPANY BUY SHARES IN A DUTCH CARIBBEAN COMPANY?
Generally speaking: yes
Under Netherlands Antilles law, no specific requirements exist regarding the purchase of shares in a Netherlands Antilles offshore company by a foreign company. The Netherlands Antilles do not have any anti-trust regulations.
In the Netherlands Antilles there are no statutory requirements preventing the sale of one or all the shares issued and outstanding or any requirements in the form of governmental license or registration. Certain restrictions apply however, if the target company is a bank or insurance company.
According to Netherlands Antillean corporate law shares are transferable, in principle. However, there is one exception. The articles of …
Read the rest »
A JOINDER BETWEEN PARTIES IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
An interest must be proved
When two parties are involved in legal proceedings a third party may request permission to join the proceedings thereby to joining with one party in raising defense against the other (‘voeging’). Alternatively, a third party may request permission to intervene (‘tussenkomen‘) in pending proceedings, in which case neither party is joined.
The Dutch Supreme Court (May 3, 1957, NJ 1959, nr. 62) ruled that a joinder between parties in pending proceedings may only be sustained if the party requesting the joinder have an evident interest in supporting one of the parties’ positions, and thus in …
Read the rest »
PLEDGING FUTURE RECEIVABLES IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Bankruptcy pledgor will prevent valid pledge
Under the laws of the Netherlands Antilles, a right of pledge may be established on future receivables, however, the right of pledge on a future receivable will only be perfected the moment such a receivable comes into existence, provided that, at such a time, the pledgor is authorized to dispose over or encumber such receivables (‘beschikkingsbevoegd’).
Therefore, if a pledgor has been granted a suspension of payments (‘surséance van betaling verleend’) or has been declared bankrupt (‘failliet verklaard’) in the Netherlands Antilles, before a future receivable, directly resulting from an existing legal relationship, comes …
Read the rest »
PREJUDICED INTERESTS OF MINORITY SHAREHOLDERS IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
A minority shareholder may force the company to take-over his shares
Article 2:251(1) Netherlands Antilles Civil Code reads as follows: “A shareholder of registered shares, whose rights or interests are prejudiced to such an extent, by the conduct of the company or one or more co-shareholders, that a continuation of his shareholding cannot reasonably be required of him, may institute a claim against the company for withdrawal, demanding that his shares be acquired against payment in cash”.
This provision may only be successfully triggered in exceptional circumstances. This could be the case if the company or co-shareholders have a structural policy …
Read the rest »
DRAG-ALONG RIGHTS UNDER THE LAWS OF THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Drag-along rights may be validly created
A drag-along right is a right that enables a majority shareholder to force a minority shareholder to join in the sale of his shares in a company (NV or BV). The majority shareholder doing the dragging must give the minority shareholder the same price, terms, and conditions that apply to him. The question with regards to Dutch Caribbean law is whether the articles of association of an NV or BV may contain drag-along provisions.
Article 2:257(1) of the Netherlands Antilles Civil Code reads as follows: “The articles may provide that, in cases to be …
Read the rest »
WHAT IF A LENDER BECOMES A SHAREHOLDER OF THE BORROWER IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN?
The obligation to repay still ranks pari passu
If a lender takes over the shares in a borrower, the ranking of the borrower’s obligation to repay the loan does not change. Such obligations will continue to rank pari passu with the other creditors.
Let me give you an example. In the event of dissolution of the borrower, assuming the borrower is a company, all creditors must be satisfied as far as possible. A shareholder is, however, not considered to be a creditor of the company.
Under Article 2:30(1) of the Netherlands Antilles Civil Code, the liquidator must realize the assets …
Read the rest »
DECLARING DIVIDENDS IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Resolutions only marginally examined by the court
Directly connected to the approval of annual accounts, the general meeting of the NV (or BV, as the case may be) or any other body designated in the articles of incorporation, shall resolve the distribution or reservation of profits according to aforementioned annual accounts and the payment of any other distributions flowing from the equity capital as apparent from the annual accounts. The general meeting, or any other body designated in the articles, may resolve to pay interim distributions for the account of the current financial year or for the account of a …
Read the rest »
DUTCH CARIBBEAN PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW
The legal effects doctrine: an exception to the lex loci delicti rule
Under Dutch Caribbean rules of private international law, a claim arising from an unlawful act is governed, in the absence of a choice of jurisdiction by the parties, by the law of the country were the unlawful act was committed (lex loci delicti). However, this rule may possibly not apply if the tortfeasor and the injured party are both residing in a country other than that where the unlawful act was committed and if the legal effects occur entirely in the other country. This is the so-called legal …
Read the rest »
INADEQUATE CAPITALIZATION IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Liability for thin-capitalization?
In terms of ‘piercing the corporate veil’, thin or inadequate capitalization usually means capitalization that is not in proportion to the nature of the risks the business of the corporation necessarily entails; in other words it is based on likely economic needs rather than legal requirements.
Shareholders of a company in the Netherlands Antilles are under an obligation to pay to the company what is due with respect to the shares, i.e. the shareholder’s capital contribution, and such contribution may not be withdrawn without due process. This is the only financial obligation of a shareholder towards the …
Read the rest »
THE FINANCIALS OF A DUTCH CARIBBEAN COMPANY
Management’s responsibility
According to Netherlands Antilles law, annually, within eight months after the company’s financial year has ended, (unless this term has been extended by the general meeting) annual statements must be drawn up by the management board and submitted to the general meeting of shareholders. The annual statements, comprising the balance sheet, profit and loss account and an explanatory statement, should be signed by all the directors.
The annual statements should be approved by the general meeting of shareholders. Said meeting can and, when this is prescribed by the articles of association, shall appoint an expert to regularly supervise the bookkeeping and to report to …
Read the rest »
MORATORIUM OF PAYMENTS IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN (II)
The debtor may make an offer of composition
The nature of a Netherlands Antilles’ moratorium differs substantially from a moratorium under US law and does, in particular, not cause pending proceedings to be stayed. Generally, a moratorium in the Netherlands Antilles protects a debtor from claims existing at the time of the moratorium. It does not prevent litigating such claims, but judgments obtained cannot be enforced.
During a moratorium, the creditor is prevented from enforcing ordinary agreements against the party to which the moratorium is granted. Instead, creditors may file their claims with the administrator in the moratorium. If the performance of the …
Read the rest »