COURTS AND OMBUDSMAN REPORTS

Ombudsman reports are taken seriously

An Ombudsman determines whether a complaint is justified or not. If the Ombudsman finds that a complaint is justified or has merit, he may decide to try and persuade the government or government agency to change its policy or decision. This topic, however, is about an Ombudsman report resulting from a complaint primarily filed to establish whether there were sufficient grounds to initiate legal proceedings in a regular court. A lawyer and his client may decide to submit the Ombudsman report to the court, in the course of proceedings, as evidence that supports the client’s …
Read the rest »

19
Jul 2012
CATEGORY

Legal

COMMENTS No Comments

OMBUDSMAN INVESTIGATION

Ombudsman beneficial to lawyers and their clients?

In several jurisdictions the law provides that, with certain exceptions, a statement made or an answer given by a person during an investigation by the Ombudsman, and a report or recommendation of the Ombudsman, is inadmissible in evidence in a court or in any other proceeding.

As far as legal proceedings in the Dutch Caribbean are concerned, our laws do not prohibit an Ombudsman’s report from being introduced into a civil lawsuit. Based on an Ombudsman’s report one may report a case to the police or the public prosecutor’s office. It should be …
Read the rest »

12
Jul 2012
CATEGORY

Legal

COMMENTS No Comments

LAWYERS COMPARED TO OMBUDSMEN

Tarzan in the administration jungle

I will not go into too much detail regarding the role and nature of an Ombudsman and investigations carried out by him. The role of Ombudsman is known in many jurisdictions and they can, just like lawyers, be found in all types and sizes. Some are described as “Tarzan in the administration jungle”. I will merely attempt to only highlight a few of the differences between an Ombudsman and a lawyer.

An Ombudsman is the obvious person for civilians to approach with their complaints about government and government agencies. The main task of the Ombudsman …
Read the rest »

07
Jul 2012
CATEGORY

Legal

COMMENTS No Comments

LAWYERS IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN

What is a lawyer?

For people dealing with lawyers it is of importance to understand lawyers as a profession and what they may be after in a particular case. I will therefore briefly discuss the nature of this centuries old profession.

Well, what is a lawyer? The answer depends on the context in which this question is posed. In the Dutch Caribbean Islands (Aruba, Bonaire, Curacao, Saint Maarten, Saint Eustatius and Saba) for instance it is a regulated and protected profession like in most other countries.

The Advocatenlandsverordening 1959 [Lawyers National Ordinance 1959] talks about persons who practice a profession …
Read the rest »

29
Jun 2012
COMMENTS No Comments

GOVERNMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE (V)

Government drafted model articles of association

The first model articles of association date from March 15, 2011.

For criticism see: K. Frielink, Visie Land op overheids-NV’s verkeerd [Vision Country on government-owned NVs incorrect], Antilliaans Dagblad 15 April 2011, p. 16 and M.L. Alexander, F.B.M. Kunneman, L.G. Santine and R.J. in ’t Veld, Modelstatuten ten sterkste afgeraden [Model articles of association strongly discouraged], Antilliaans Dagblad 20 September 2011, p. 14-15. See also K. Frielink, Stop politieke benoemings- en ontslagcarrousel [Stop politicial appointment and dismissal merry-go-round], Antilliaans Dagblad 14 September 2010, p. 14-15.

In the meantime, the models for …
Read the rest »

21
Jun 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments

GOVERNMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE (IV)

Code Corporate Governance Curacao

On January 1, 2010, the National Ordinance regarding corporate governance came into effect. Based on this the Code Corporate Governance Curacao came into being, that also came into effect on January 1, 2010. In it, reference is still made to the Executive Council and the island territory of Curacao, but as from October 10, 2010 these are understood to mean the government of Curacao and the Country Curacao.

The National Ordinance does not only undertake to establish a corporate governance code, but also to implement the Code in the government-owned companies. In 2011, this implementation obligation …
Read the rest »

14
Jun 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments

GOVERNMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE (III)

The government is not automatically an ‘ordinary’ shareholder

It is obvious that in a small community such as that of Curacao, with only a limited choice when it comes to directors and supervisory directors to be appointed, and in which (family, social) networks seem to play an important role in making choices, there is a field of tension. It is even more important therefore that government has a clear vision regarding its shareholdership and that there are good and transparent procedures, e.g. regarding the appointment of directors and supervisory directors.

Does the obligation exist for the government to, briefly stated, …
Read the rest »

07
Jun 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments

GOVERNMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE (II)

Government (not) at a distance?

Being a director of a government-owned company is certainly not always as easy. Neither is being a shareholder in a government-owned company. The directors will usually complain about too much influence from politicians, while the politicians will usually find that they have too little grip on government-owned companies. In this connection, there are two important topics we will have to consider briefly.

I will ignore cultural aspects here. In that respect see e.g. chapter 8 of the dissertation of A. van Marrewijk, Internationalisation, cooperation and ethnicity in the telecom sector, Delft: Uitgeverij Eburon 1999, 340 …
Read the rest »

31
May 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments

GOVERNMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE (I)

For Hobbes, it is certain that there must be a sovereign

According to Thomas Hobbes we all have natural passions that carry us to, among other things, partiality, pride, and revenge. The laws of nature, as Hobbes sees them, including ‘justice’, ‘equity’, ‘modesty’, and ‘mercy’, are contrary to our passions. Therefore, we will only observe the laws of nature if we have fear of some power to cause them to be observed. According to him, covenants, without the sword, are but words that lack every strength to protect a person.

See Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, Amsterdam: Boom 2007, p. 207 and …
Read the rest »

24
May 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments

CURACAO COURT INTERVENES IN POLITICAL APPOINTMENT

Political appointments unacceptable

The Court of First Instance of Curacao passed judgment on 23 January 2012 in the case of Selikor N.V. versus Drs. Ivar Asjes (JOR 2012, 105). This case is a follow-up to the judgment of the Joint Court of Appeal of the Netherlands Antilles and Aruba of 10 August 2010, JOR 2010, 296. In a nutshell the case boils down to Asjes being appointed as the managing director of waste processor Selikor N.V., but that this is an appointment pushed through politically without an open job application procedure. This deprived at least six of Selikor’s members of …
Read the rest »

12
May 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments

DUTCH CARIBBEAN LEGAL PORTAL

Aruba, Bonaire, Curacao, St. Maarten, St. Eustatius and Saba

There is a large legal community in the Dutch Caribbean. Until 2007 there was no website with news and general information about the legal system of the Dutch Caribbean, its institutions and its practitioners. Dutch Caribbean Legal Portal aims to fill this void and strives to be the complete database of Legal News, Contacts and Documents for the Dutch Caribbean.

The DC Legal Portal has a wide variety of members and contacts within the legal and financial areas of the Dutch Caribbean. It has a database of more …
Read the rest »

07
May 2012
CATEGORY

Legal

COMMENTS No Comments

INQUIRY PROCEDURE IN CURACAO

Important court decision for the local trust practice

On 30 March 2012 the first petition for an inquiry procedure under the new law was dealt with by the Joint Court of Justice of Aruba, Curacao and St. Maarten, and of Bonaire, St. Eustatius and Saba. Karel Frielink and Dinesh Mishre had the honor of acting as lawyers for the defense … and with success! This decision is very important for the companies in Curacao and especially for the local trust offices.

As of 1 January 2012 the amended Corporate Code (Book 2 Civil Code) of Curacao entered into force. The …
Read the rest »

02
May 2012
CATEGORY

Corporate

COMMENTS No Comments