APPELLATE PROCEEDINGS IN THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN
Full review of the case
Appellate proceedings in the Dutch Caribbean provide for a full review of the appealed decision: the grounds on which the Appellate Court can reverse the original judgment are not, as in certain other jurisdictions, limited to procedural matters. It is furthermore permissible to introduce new documentary evidence in the course of appellate proceedings. If the appealed judgment contains a final decision as regards the dispute the Appellate Court will either confirm the judgment or it will itself render a replacing decision: the case will not be referred back to the Court of First Instance.
Furthermore, …
Read the rest »
INSURANCE BUSINESS IN ARUBA (II)
Different insurance contracts
According to the SOSIB a “life insurance agreement” is an insurance contract concerning the payment of cash benefits related to the life or death of man, and a “general insurance contract” is an insurance contract, other than a life insurance contract.
Generally, an insurance contract is understood to be an agreement whereby an insurer commits itself to the insured, against receipt of a premium, to compensate the latter for a loss, damage or loss of expected advantage which the insured could suffer as a result of an uncertain event.
There is no existing case-law or regulatory directive …
Read the rest »
INSURANCE BUSINESS IN ARUBA (I)
The Central Bank of Aruba is the regulator
The Central Bank of Aruba supervises insurers incorporated in Aruba and the branches and agencies in Aruba of insurers incorporated outside Aruba based on the State Ordinance on the Supervision of the Insurance Business (SOSIB).
The SOSIB, effective since 2001, stipulates that life and non-life insurance business must be carried out by separate legal entities. The Central Bank of Aruba shall decide whether an action or a combination of actions does or does not constitute as being engaged in the life insurance business or the general insurance business, and whether an action …
Read the rest »
CREDIT INSTITUTIONS IN ARUBA
A license is required
According to Section 4 of the Aruba State Ordinance on the Supervision of the Credit System 1998 (SOSC), no enterprise or institution established in Aruba shall pursue the business of a credit institution unless it has obtained authorization to that end from the Central Bank. No enterprise or institution established outside Aruba shall pursue the business of a credit institution through a branch in Aruba, unless it has obtained authorization from the Central Bank to do so (Section 24(1) SOSC).
A “credit institution” under the SOSC means an enterprise or institution, not being an institution established …
Read the rest »
THE CURACAO MEMBER-MANAGED COMPANY
The right form for small businesses
Until March 1, 2004 only manager managed companies were known. According to the current Curacao Civil Code, the articles of a company may provide that such company be a member managed company, which is a company without a board of directors. The shareholders (members) are then in charge of the company, including its day-to-day affairs. A member managed company is suitable for smaller companies, e.g. family businesses, with only one or a few shareholders.
If such designation is absent in the articles of a company, the company will be a manager managed company. The designation …
Read the rest »
THE CURACAO PRIVATE FOUNDATION
A Private Foundation can be used for tax planning and asset protection The Curacao Private Foundation was introduced by the National Ordinance Regarding Foundations as published on October 31, 1998. Since March 1st, 2004, these rules are laid down in Book 2 of the Curacao Civil Code. The Private Foundation possesses corporate personality but does not have share capital. The Private Foundation is incorporated by deed executed before a Curacao public notary and is registered in the Register of Foundations at the Curacao Chamber of Commerce. The object of the Private Foundation may include a number of activities, and is …
Read the rest »
THE ENFORCEMENT OF A JUDGEMENT BY THE COURTS IN CURACAO
Judgments are immediately enforceable most of the time
According to Article 55, par. 1 of the Curacao Code of Civil Procedure, opposition (in the case of a default judgment) or appeal (in the event of adversarial proceedings) prevent the enforcement (execution) of a judgment unless the decision is ‘enforceable notwithstanding opposition or appeal’ a.k.a. a judgment which is declared ‘immediately enforceable’ (‘uitvoerbaar bij voorraad is verklaard’).
The submission of an appeal results, therefore, in a stay of execution, unless the first-instance court, on a motion by one of the parties, has declared its judgment enforceable even if it is challenged …
Read the rest »
THE DUTCH CARIBBEAN JUDICIAL SYSTEM
A well developed system
The judicial system of the various islands in the Dutch Caribbean (Aruba, Bonaire, Curacao, St. Maarten, Saba and St. Eustatius) is independent, has a long history, and is well developed. It is capable of resolving complex commercial disputes in a just and efficient manner. The judges in the Dutch Caribbean are well-trained, professional judges.
In general, parties in civil proceedings have the right to appeal to the Joint Court of Appeal of Aruba, Curacao and St. Maarten and of Bonaire, Sint Eustatius en Saba (‘Gemeenschappelijk Hof van Justitie van Aruba, Curacao en St. Maarten en van …
Read the rest »
THE RHYTHM AND BLUES OF CURACAO CONTRACT LAW
Principle of fairness and reasonableness
When considered in the perspective of the laws of Curacao, the reliance on or the enforcement of contractual terms and conditions contained in any agreement, may under certain circumstances be contrary to the overriding principle of ‘fairness and reasonableness’ (redelijkheid en billijkheid) which governs the relationship between the parties to an agreement. Prof. Tjittes calls this good faith principle the Rhythm & Blues of our legal system.
Civil law systems such as the Dutch, French, German, or our system, explicitly espouse and apply this principle, whereas common law systems (e.g. English common law) do not …
Read the rest »
U.S. JUDGMENTS AND CURACAO
The recognition and enforceability of foreign judgments in the absence of a treaty
In the absence of an applicable treaty between foreign countries (for example the U.S.) and Curacao, a judgment rendered by a U.S. court will not be enforced by Curacaoan courts. In order to obtain a judgment which is enforceable in Curacao the claim must be re-litigated before the Curacao courts.
Nevertheless, a judgment rendered by a U.S. Court will, under current practice, be recognized by a Curacaoan court
Read the rest »
SECURITIZATION IN CURACAO
Curacaoan special purpose vehicles are commonly used in cross–border financing transactions
Curacaoan special purpose vehicles (SPVs) are commonly used in both cross–border financing transactions as well as in Curacao domestic financing transactions. As far as cross–border transactions are concerned, (synthetic and cash) securitizations, repackagings, collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), collateralized loan obligations (CLOs), leasing transactions, MTN and other note issuance programs are among the most popular transactions involving a Curacao SPV.
There are a number of reasons that make Curacao an attractive jurisdiction in which to set up SPVs in structured financing transactions. The first of these is the favorable Curacaoan …
Read the rest »
THE ANNUAL ACCOUNTS OF A LARGE CURACAO COMPANY
Stricter rules for large companies
Under Curacao law the annual accounts of limited liability companies which do not qualify as so called large companies, need to be prepared in accordance with generally accepted standards and shall provide sufficient insight as to enable a sound judgment to be formed regarding the assets and the results and, to the extent the nature of the annual accounts so permit, regarding the solvency and liquidity of the company (article 2:116 (4) Curacao Civil Code). This is comparable to the principles of good business practice (goed koopmansgebruik).
For large companies the legislator chose a tighter …
Read the rest »